Kitty Litter Cake might not sound like your go-to dessert, but it’s a guaranteed hit at any Halloween or gag-worthy party. This quirky cake is made to look exactly like—yep, you guessed it—kitty litter, complete with crumbled cake, crushed cookies, and melted Tootsie Roll “poop.”
But don’t let the appearance fool you! Beneath the gross-out factor is a delicious blend of chocolate, vanilla, and crunchy textures that make it fun to eat and serve.
The first time I made this for a Halloween party, the reactions were priceless. Watching guests hesitantly try it, then go back for seconds, was a highlight.
It’s all about the shock value, and with its growing popularity, this cake is now a must for any themed gathering. Best part? It’s surprisingly easy to make, even with the hilarious presentation.
Why I Love This Recipe?
- It’s a guaranteed party hit: The reactions are priceless, and no one can resist talking about it.
- Super easy to make: Despite its elaborate appearance, it’s really just a fun twist on cake and cookies.
- Perfect for Halloween: It’s gross in the best way possible and sets the mood for any spooky celebration.
- A fun project for all ages: Kids and adults love helping put together the “poop” and “litter.”
Try More Cake Recipes!
Kitty Litter Cake Recipe
Equipment
- Mixing Bowl
- Measuring Cups
- Spatula
- Cake Pan
- Cake Tester
- Plastic Scoop
- Shallow Pan
- Food Processor
Ingredients
- 1 box vanilla cake mix
- 1 box chocolate cake mix
- small tootsie rolls
- 1 5.1 oz pkg vanilla instant pudding
- green food coloring
- 1 pkg golden oreos
Instructions
- Mix and bake the cake according to the package instructions, then let it cool.
- Make the pudding as directed and chill it in the fridge.
- Crush the Oreos in a food processor, saving some for later. Add green food coloring to a portion for that “litter” effect.
- Crumble the cooled cakes into a clean kitty litter tray. Layer with half of the plain cookie crumbs and half of the chilled pudding.
- Soften the Tootsie Rolls in the microwave and shape them into “poops,” then scatter them over the cake.
- Sprinkle the remaining plain cookie crumbs and green crumbs over the top. Finish with more Tootsie Roll “poops” and serve with a clean pooper scooper.
Notes
- Try using cheesecake-flavored pudding instead of vanilla for a different twist, or go even further and use pistachio pudding for a more playful and gross appearance.
- Don’t worry about the cake falling through the pooper scooper; the cake mixture is thick enough to hold its shape and scoop easily.
Nutrition
Time for The Tips!
- Get creative with pudding flavors! While vanilla pudding works great, you can switch things up by using cheesecake pudding for a different twist. For those looking to amp up the “gross factor,” pistachio pudding can add an extra level of visual interest.
- Don’t stress about the baking pans. Since the cakes will be crumbled anyway, it doesn’t matter what you bake them in. Use whatever you have on hand or prefer.
- Don’t worry about the cake falling through the scoop. The cake mixture will be thick enough to hold its shape, ensuring that it won’t slip through the holes of the pooper scooper. So scoop away without any concerns!
What to Serve with Kitty Litter Cake?
